Pope Leo XIV, the first U.S.-born pope, made rare public remarks on American politics, describing President Donald Trump’s recent military speeches as “concerning” and urging Catholics to reconsider what it truly means to be pro-life. The pontiff’s comments touch on migration, the death penalty, and the ethical responsibilities of political leaders.

Speaking outside his Castel Gandolfo residence, Leo emphasized that political discourse should reduce tension and promote peace rather than conflict.

“This way of speaking is concerning, because it shows, every time, an increase of tension,” Leo said, noting that phrases like “minister of war” were alarming but hoped they were mere figures of speech.

Pope Leo Critiques Political Rhetoric

The pope was asked about a meeting of U.S. military leaders in Virginia, where Trump and Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth gave highly partisan speeches. Leo stressed the importance of working toward peace and avoiding escalation.

While critical of the tone, Leo endorsed the Trump administration’s proposed peace plan for Gaza, calling it “realistic” and hoping for its acceptance.

Vatican analyst Marco Politi described Leo’s remarks as the sharpest criticism yet of Trumpist ideology, while noting the pope’s measured approach.

Redefining “Pro-Life” in the Modern Era

Pope Leo also addressed ethical inconsistencies in American politics. Referring to Sen. Dick Durbin’s work on immigration, Leo highlighted that pro-life values must go beyond opposing abortion, encompassing issues like:

• The humane treatment of migrants
• Opposition to the death penalty

“Someone who says, ‘I am against abortion but I am in favor of the death penalty,’ is not really pro-life,” Leo said. He urged Catholics and citizens alike to examine a politician’s overall ethical record rather than isolated stances.

READ ALSO

Will the Global Sumud Flotilla break through Israel’s naval blockade of Gaza?

Why Madeleine Dean thinks Trump is “unhinged”, and how Speaker Johnson reacted

The Broader Impact on the U.S. Catholic Church

Leo’s comments come amid divisions within the American Catholic Church, as leaders and parishioners grapple with partisan divides. Archbishop Blase J. Cupich withdrew a planned award for Senator Durbin after criticism over his stance on abortion, reflecting tensions within church leadership.

The pope’s message encourages respectful dialogue, nuanced judgment, and unity within the church. Leo’s approach contrasts with Pope Francis, who was often more openly critical of Trump’s policies, particularly on migration.

Why Pope Leo’s Words Matter

• Leo XIV is the first U.S.-born pope, offering a unique perspective on American politics.
• His remarks remind the faithful that ethical principles should guide political engagement, not partisan allegiance.
• The focus on human dignity and justice reflects the Vatican’s ongoing commitment to global humanitarian concerns.

Leo’s comments serve as a call for Catholics to consider comprehensive ethical frameworks, rather than reducing pro-life principles to single issues.

FAQ

Q1: Who is Pope Leo XIV?

A1: Pope Leo XIV is the first U.S.-born pope, elected in 2025. He previously served as bishop in Chiclayo, Peru, and emphasizes human dignity and ethical leadership.

Q2: What did Pope Leo XIV say about President Trump?

A2: He described Trump’s military speeches as “concerning” and cautioned that such rhetoric increases tension, urging efforts toward peace.

Q3: What does Pope Leo XIV mean by “pro-life”?

A3: Pope Leo emphasizes that being pro-life includes opposing abortion, the death penalty, and inhumane treatment of migrants, promoting a holistic ethical approach.

Q4: Did Pope Leo support Trump’s Gaza peace plan?

A4: Yes, Pope Leo called the proposed plan “realistic” and expressed hope that it would be accepted.

Q5: Why did Pope Leo comment on Senator Durbin and Chicago’s archdiocese?

A5: He addressed the ethical complexity of honoring a politician who supports immigration reform but also abortion rights, emphasizing nuanced evaluation of public service.

Q6: How does Pope Leo XIV differ from Pope Francis?

A6: While Francis was more openly critical of Trump, Leo takes a balanced approach, avoiding partisan polarization and focusing on ethical principles and unity.

Q7: What is the significance of Pope Leo’s U.S. political comments?

A7: His remarks guide Catholics to carefully consider ethical consistency in political leaders and encourage respect, dialogue, and unity within the church.

Q8: How should Catholics apply Pope Leo’s guidance?

A8: Catholics are urged to evaluate political issues comprehensively, prioritize human dignity, and avoid reducing pro-life values to a single issue.

Q9: Where did Pope Leo XIV make these remarks?

A9: Outside his residence at Castel Gandolfo, Italy, during an unusual press interaction on September 30, 2025.

Q10: Is Pope Leo XIV engaging in partisan politics?

A10: No, he emphasizes ethical reflection and peace, deliberately avoiding explicit partisan alignment.