Foreign nationals who have lived and worked in Germany for several years may still be refused citizenship if they fail to meet certain legal and constitutional requirements.
Germany’s Citizenship Act identifies three major grounds under which naturalisation applications can be rejected, covering activities that threaten national security, serious conduct that may justify expulsion and behaviour that conflicts with the country’s constitutional principles.
The restrictions are outlined in Section 11 of Germany’s Citizenship Act and apply to foreigners seeking to become German citizens through naturalisation.
The provisions show that meeting the required residence period does not automatically guarantee citizenship. Applicants must also satisfy the country’s legal conditions and demonstrate respect for its democratic constitutional order.
1. Activities That Threaten Germany’s Democratic Constitutional Order
The first ground for refusing citizenship concerns foreigners who pursue, support or have previously participated in activities directed against Germany’s free democratic constitutional system.
Under Section 11, naturalisation may be refused where there are concrete indications that an applicant has engaged in activities intended to undermine the constitutional order, threaten the security of Germany or any of its federal states, or obstruct the functioning of constitutional institutions through violence or preparations for violence.
The restriction also covers activities capable of damaging Germany’s foreign interests.
However, the law provides an opportunity for certain applicants to overcome this exclusion.
A foreigner may no longer be barred on this ground if they credibly demonstrate that they have genuinely abandoned or distanced themselves from the activities in question.
There is also a related restriction involving false declarations made during the naturalisation process. Where concrete evidence suggests that an applicant’s declaration was false, this can provide grounds for exclusion.
2. Serious Conduct That Creates an Interest in Expelling the Applicant
The second ground concerns foreigners whose circumstances fall under the particularly serious expulsion-interest provisions of Germany’s Residence Act.
These provisions generally address serious criminal conduct and circumstances that raise significant public safety or security concerns.
The citizenship authority may consider whether an applicant’s conduct meets the legal threshold for a particularly serious interest in expulsion.
This means that foreigners who have lived in Germany for an extended period may still face rejection if their conduct falls within the relevant provisions.
The assessment is based on the applicable legal requirements rather than simply the number of years an applicant has spent in the country.
READ ALSO
Germany Sets Travel Limits for Foreigners Applying for Citizenship: What Applicants Need to Know
3. Polygamy and Disrespect for Gender Equality
The third ground covers two personal conduct issues that can make a foreigner ineligible for German citizenship.
The first concerns polygamy. A person who is married to more than one spouse at the same time cannot obtain German citizenship through naturalisation under the relevant provision.
The second concerns an applicant’s attitude towards the equal rights of men and women.
Germany’s Basic Law guarantees equality between men and women. Under the Citizenship Act, foreigners whose conduct demonstrates that they do not respect this constitutional principle may be excluded from naturalisation.
These requirements reflect Germany’s expectation that people seeking citizenship accept the fundamental values underpinning its constitutional and legal system.
What Germany’s Citizenship Rules Mean for Foreign Applicants
Germany’s naturalisation requirements go beyond residence and other standard eligibility conditions.
Section 11 establishes circumstances in which an applicant may be excluded even if they have fulfilled other requirements for citizenship.
Foreigners planning to apply should understand that their conduct, associations and declarations during the application process may be relevant to the decision.
The law also distinguishes between different grounds for exclusion. For instance, applicants affected by the constitutional-security provision may be able to demonstrate that they have genuinely distanced themselves from their previous activities. The other grounds have their own legal requirements and should not be treated as having identical exceptions.
Anyone concerned that their personal circumstances could affect a citizenship application should seek advice from a qualified German immigration lawyer or the relevant naturalisation authority.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Can Germany deny citizenship to foreigners who have lived there for many years?
Yes. Meeting the residence requirement does not guarantee naturalisation. Applicants can still be excluded under Section 11 of Germany’s Citizenship Act if they fall within specified legal grounds.
2. Can a foreigner with criminal convictions obtain German citizenship?
It depends on the nature and seriousness of the conduct and the applicable provisions of German law. Certain serious circumstances that create a particularly serious interest in expulsion can prevent naturalisation.
3. Does Germany allow foreigners with more than one spouse to obtain citizenship?
Under Section 11, a foreigner who is simultaneously married to more than one spouse is excluded from naturalisation.
4. Can Germany reject a citizenship application over gender equality?
Yes. An applicant whose conduct demonstrates that they do not respect the equal rights of men and women, as guaranteed by Germany’s Basic Law, can be excluded.
5. Can someone previously involved in activities against Germany still obtain citizenship?
Potentially. The law provides that an applicant may overcome the relevant exclusion if they credibly demonstrate that they have genuinely distanced themselves from the activities.
6. Which German law explains reasons foreigners can be denied citizenship?
Section 11 of Germany’s Citizenship Act (Staatsangehörigkeitsgesetz or StAG) outlines circumstances in which foreigners may be excluded from naturalisation.



