Vitinha’s Ballon d’Or case: Can Portugal midfielder claim the award?

As the football world gears up for the 2025 Ballon d’Or ceremony later this year, a new name is emerging from the shadows of midfield brilliance: Vitinha of Portugal and Paris Saint-Germain (PSG). The 24-year-old Portuguese midfielder has ignited debates among fans and analysts, with many arguing that his achievements in the 2024/25 season similar and in some cases surpass those of Rodri, who claimed the prestigious award in 2024. Rodri’s victory, driven by his pivotal role in Manchester City’s Premier League triumph and Spain’s Euro 2024 success, set a record for recognizing midfielders’ impact. Now, Vitinha’s remarkable campaign, including a Champions League title, Ligue 1 dominance, and a Nations League triumph, has sparked a compelling case for him to join the race for the Ballon d’Or. This piece is set to explore Vitinha’s standout season, compares it to Rodri’s 2023/24 achievements, and argue why the Portuguese star deserves the award.

Vitinha’s 2024/25 triumphs

Vitinha’s 2024/25 season with PSG has been sensational. The midfielder was the anchor in PSG’s treble-winning campaign, securing the Ligue 1 title, the Coupe de France, and the UEFA Champions League. His stats tell a compelling story: 8 goals and 12 assists in 48 appearances across all competitions, with a pass completion rate of 88% and 2.1 key passes per 90 minutes, according to recent performance data. Internationally, Vitinha has been equally influential, guiding Portugal pass Germany in the UEFA Nations League semi-finals, and securing the title against Spain.

His 1.5 tackles per 90 and 1.8 dribbles per 90 highlight his versatility, while his composure under pressure has drawn comparisons to Xavi Hernandez. PSG coach Luis Enrique has publicly lauded him and fans on social media marvel at his ability to control tempo and elevate teammates. With the Club World Cup looming in mid-June, Vitinha’s potential to add another trophy could further cement his credentials.

Comparison to Rodri’s 2023/24 record

Rodri’s 2024 Ballon d’Or win was a historic moment, marking the first time a defensive midfielder claimed the award since Lothar Matthaus in 1990. His 2023/24 season with Manchester City saw him secure a record fourth consecutive Premier League title, the UEFA Super Cup, and the FIFA Club World Cup, culminating in 8 goals and 9 assists in 34 Premier League starts. Internationally, Rodri was named Euro 2024 Player of the Tournament, leading Spain to glory with a perfect campaign, including a 2-1 final win over England. His over 1000 touches and 85% pass completion rate in the Premier League showed his role as the heartbeat of both club and country, a factor that swayed voters despite competition from Vinicius Jr’s La Liga and Champions League double.

At first, Vitinha’s 2024/25 achievements align closely with Rodri’s 2023/24. Both have led their clubs to domestic league titles: Ligue 1 for Vitinha and the Premier League for Rodri demonstrating sustained excellence in big competitions. Vitinha’s Champions League triumph mirrors Rodri’s Club World Cup success. Internationally, Vitinha’s Nations League triumph can be compared to Rodri’s Euro 2024 victory. Statistically, Vitinha’s 8 goals and 12 assists edge out Rodri’s 8 and 9, while his higher pass completion (88% vs. 85%) and key pass rate (2.1 vs. 1.6) suggest a more dynamic offensive contribution.

RELATED STORIES

Ousmane Dembele: How Barcelona Injury Prone Forward Became PSG Talisman

What football fans will never forget in 2025

Mohamed Salah’s Ballon d’Or race: Can the Egyptian King claim the award?

The key difference lies in the stage of recognition. Rodri’s Euro 2024 Player of the Tournament award gave him an individual accolade that Vitinha has yet to match, though Vitinha’s strong Nations League final performance could shift the narrative. However, Vitinha’s role in PSG’s treble arguably carries greater weight than Rodri’s three trophies, given the Champions League’s prestige over the Super Cup and Club World Cup. Fans and analysts on social media have noted Vitinha’s consistency across more matches, suggesting a broader impact that demands equal, if not greater, consideration.

Why Vitinha deserves the Ballon d’Or

Vitinha’s case for the 2025 Ballon d’Or rests on several compelling arguments. First, his Champions League triumph, which is football’s most cherished club competition outshines Rodri’s Club World Cup, offering a direct comparison to Vinícius’ 2023/24 success, which fell short in the voting. Second, his treble with PSG demonstrates a versatility and influence across multiple competitions, a feat Rodri did not achieve in a single season to win the award. Third, Vitinha’s youth (24 vs. Rodri’s 28) and upward trajectory suggest a player at the peak of greatness, potentially mirroring the career arcs of past winners like Modric.

Critics might argue Rodri’s Euro 2024 Player of the Tournament title gives him an edge, but Vitinha’s potential to lead Portugal to Nations League glory has level the playing field. His ability to thrive in tight spaces, as praised by Enrique, and his game-changing moments in the Champions League final align with the Ballon d’Or’s emphasis on decisiveness. Moreover, the award’s evolution toward recognizing midfield maestros, as seen with Rodri, supports Vitinha’s candidacy, especially if voters prioritize current form over past records.

What football fans think about Vitinha’s Ballon d’Or contention

The football community is divided, with social media buzzing with comparisons. Some fans argue Vitinha’s snub from top-five discussions is unjust, pointing to his treble and Nations League final heroics, while others caution that Rodri’s established reputation might sway voters again. The narrative of a “new era” after Messi and Ronaldo, initiated by Rodri’s 2024 win, could favour Vitinha as the next winner, especially if he outshines peers like Haaland or Mbappe in the Club World Cup. His humble rise from Wolves to PSG’s midfield general is a criteria for the award.

Conclusion

Vitinha’s 2024/25 season presents a Ballon d’Or case as robust as Rodri’s 2023/24 triumph, with a Champions League title, a domestic treble, and international semi-final success matching or exceeding Rodri’s achievements. His statistical edge, youthful promise, and clutch performances make him a deserving contender, challenging the notion that past awards dictate future winners. As the Nations League final and Club World Cup loom, Vitinha has a chance to seal his legacy. If he seizes it, the 2025 Ballon d’Or could crown a new midfield king, proving that Portugal’s quiet maestro deserves to stand alongside or even above Rodri in football’s storied history.