Fergie Time: Five most impossible comebacks in United history

Manchester United’s storied history is woven with moments of defying the odds, where the Red Devils have snatched victory from the jaws of defeat in ways that seems magical. From European nights to domestic battles, United’s ability for impossible comebacks has solidified their reputation as a club that never surrenders. The latest chapter, a jaw-dropping 5-4 win over Lyon in the 2024/25 UEFA Europa League quarter-final, has reignited the debate: which of United’s comebacks is the greatest? This piece is set to explore five of the most impossible turnarounds, analyzing their context, execution, and impact, before deciding the ultimate comeback.

Manchester United 5-4 Lyon (7-6 agg), UEFA Europa League Quarter-Final, April 17, 2025

Trailing 2-2 after the first leg in Lyon, United hosted the French side at Old Trafford in a pulsating quarter-final. Under Ruben Amorim, United were chasing Europa League glory to secure Champions League qualification, but their inconsistent season 14th in the Premier League made this a must-win.

United started with a 2-0 lead with goals from Manuel Ugarte (10) and Diogo Dalot (51), but Lyon clawed back through Corentin Tolisso (71) and Nicolas Tagliafico (78), leveling the score at 2-2 on the night (4-4 agg). Tolisso’s red card in the 89th minute gave United a man advantage, yet Lyon stunned in extra time. Rayan Cherki (106) and Alexandre Lacazette’s penalty (110) put Lyon 4-2 up (6-4 agg) with 12 minutes left. United seemed buried, but Bruno Fernandes’ penalty (114) sparked hope. Kobbie Mainoo’s curler (120) equalized at 4-4 (6-6 agg), and Harry Maguire, pushed up as a makeshift striker, headed the winner (120+1), sparking pandemonium. It was the first European match with five extra-time goals.

Manchester United 2-1 Bayern Munich, UEFA Champions League Final, May 26, 1999

United, chasing a historic Treble under Sir Alex Ferguson, faced Bayern Munich in the 1999 Champions League final at the Nou Camp. Without Roy Keane and Paul Scholes, United were underdogs against a Bayern side led by Lothar Matthaus and Mario Basler.

Bayern took the lead through Basler’s free kick (6) and dominated, hitting the woodwork twice. United trailed 1-0 as stoppage time loomed, with Bayern fans already celebrating. In the 91st minute, Ryan Giggs’ scuffed shot from a David Beckham corner found Teddy Sheringham, who poked in. Two minutes later, Beckham’s corner met Sheringham’s flick-on, and Ole Gunnar Solskjaer tap the winner. United won 2-1, completing one of Europe’s biggest comebacks in football and the Treble.

RELATED STORY

Andre Onana: Is he really Manchester United’s worst goalkeeper?

Bruno Fernandes: United’s unsung hero, can he be called a club legend?

Opinion: Did Erik ten Hag Destroy Manchester United?

Juventus 2-3 Manchester United (3-4 agg), UEFA Champions League Semi-Final, April 21, 1999

United trailed 1-1 after the first leg at Old Trafford in the 1998/99 Champions League semi-final. Facing Juventus in Turin led by Zinedine Zidane and Filippo Inzaghi—United needed a miracle against a side unbeaten at home in Europe that season. Inzaghi’s brace (6) put Juventus 2-0 up (3-1 agg), leaving United on the brink. Roy Keane headed in Beckham’s corner (24) to spark hope, then Dwight Yorke nodded in Giggs’ cross (34) to level the tie at 3-3 agg. Andy Cole sealed the 3-2 win (84) after Yorke’s run, sending United to the final. Keane’s yellow card ruled him out of the final, but Ferguson appreciated his “selfless” display.

Paris Saint-Germain 1-3 Manchester United (3-3 agg, United win on away goals), UEFA Champions League Round of 16, March 6, 2019Under interim boss Ole Gunnar Solskjær, United faced a 2-0 deficit from the first leg at Old Trafford against a star-studded PSG side with Neymar and Kylian Mbappe. No team had overturned a two-goal home deficit in the Champions League’s knockout phase.

Romelu Lukaku pounced on a Gianluigi Buffon error (2) to make it 1-0, but Juan Bernat equalized (12), restoring PSG’s lead. Lukaku struck again (30) after Thilo Kehrer’s mistake, making it 2-1 (3-2 agg). United pressed, and in the 94th minute, a VAR-awarded penalty for Presnel Kimpembe’s handball allowed Marcus Rashford to drill home, securing a 3-1 win and progress on away goals.

Tottenham Hotspur 3-5 Manchester United, Premier League, September 29, 2001

Another of United’s comebacks happened under Ferguson. The Red devils were behind Tottenham by 3 goals at halftime in a Premier League clash at White Hart Lane. Spurs, mid-table and winless against United in years, were powered by Dean Richards, Christian Ziege, and Les Ferdinand. Spurs led through Richards (15), Ferdinand (25), and Ziege (45). Ferguson’s halftime team talk ignited United. Andy Cole pulled one back (46), followed by Laurent Blanc’s header (58). Ruud van Nistelrooy equalized (72), David Beckham’s long-range strike took the lead (76), and Juan Sebastián Verón sealed the 5-3 win (87). United scored five goals in 41 minutes.

Evaluating the greatest comeback

To determine the greatest, we assess deficit overcome, opposition quality, context, execution, and legacy

In the outcome of the deficit, Lyon (2 goals in extra time, 6-4 agg to 7-6) and Spurs (3 goals) were the largest numerical deficits. Bayern (1 goal, 90th minute) and Juventus (2 goals, 11th minute) were smaller but came against elite opposition. PSG’s two-goal aggregate deficit was historic for its rarity. Moreover, in the quality of the opposition, Bayern (1999 Bundesliga champions), Juventus (1998/99 Serie A runners-up), and PSG (2018/19 Ligue 1 champions) were top-level teams. Lyon (mid-table Ligue 1) and Spurs (mid-table Premier League) were less formidable.

Furthermore, Bayern’s final, securing the Treble, carries unmatched weight. Juventus was a semi-final en route to that Treble. Lyon’s quarter-final kept United’s season alive but lacked the final’s gravitas. PSG’s round of 16 revived Solskjaer’s tenure, while Spurs was a league game, pivotal but not season-defining. On the other hand, Lyon’s three goals in six extra-time minutes against 10-man Lyon was chaotic brilliance. Against Bayern, two goals in three minutes flipped a final. Juventus’ three goals in 60 minutes showed sustained fight. PSG’s late penalty relied on VAR, while Spurs’ five goals overwhelmed a collapsing defense.

However, Bayern’s Treble defined United’s golden era, immortalized by “Fergie Time.” Juventus paved the way for it. Lyon’s comeback, while historic, is recent and less culturally embedded. PSG’s win shaped Solskjær’s reign, and Spurs’ turnaround fueled a title charge.

The final judgement

The 1999 Champions League final comeback against Bayern Munich stands as Manchester United’s greatest. Overcoming a 1-0 deficit in stoppage time to win 2-1 in a final, against a dominant Bayern side, to secure the Treble, is unmatched in stakes and legacy. Sheringham and Solskjaer’s goals, from Beckham’s corners, in front of 90,000 at the Nou Camp, remains one of football greatest comebacks story. Lyon’s 5-4 epic comes close in second for its sheer chaos, three goals in six extra-time minutes, including Maguire’s header but its quarter-final context, against a 10-man, and mid-tier opposition cannot live up to what happened against Bayern in Europe’s biggest competition final. Juventus’ semi-final heroics rank third for their quality, followed by PSG’s Paris miracle and Spurs’ domestic rout.

Conclusion

These comebacks from Ferguson’s golden era to Amorim’s struggling tenure shows Manchester United’s legacy based on resilience, belief, and late drama. The Lyon thriller, with Mainoo’s curler and Maguire’s header, joins the list alongside Solskjaer’s tap in, Keane’s header, and Rashford’s penalty. Whether in 1999 or 2025, United’s impossible comebacks remind football enthusiasts that at Old Trafford, it is never over until the final whistle and perhaps the reason why it is called “the theatre of dreams.”