Why was Alfie Boe eliminated from Celebrity MasterChef 2025, and why fans say he was robbed?
Alfie sparked concern as he panicked in the kitchen. Image: BBC
Celebrity MasterChef 2025 delivered one of its most emotional moments yet after Alfie Boe was eliminated just days before the grand finale, sparking an outpouring of disbelief and anger from viewers. The operatic tenor, widely considered a frontrunner, bowed out during Tuesday night’s semi-final, leaving fans questioning the judges’ decision and flooding social media with support.
What Happened on Alfie Boe’s Final Celebrity MasterChef Episode
The episode saw the final four contestants, Alfie Boe, Dawn O’Porter, Alun Wyn Jones, and Ginger Johnson, tasked with creating a deeply personal dish dedicated to someone special in their lives.
For Boe, the challenge carried emotional weight. The 52-year-old singer prepared a two-layer cake in tribute to his late father, who passed away 28 years ago. One half of the dessert paid homage to his father’s favorite, Yorkshire ginger parkin, while the other referenced Boe’s celebrated stage career with a Belgian “Les Misérables”-inspired cake, complete with ginger and cinnamon-poached apricots.
Judges Praise One Half, But the Cake Proves Costly
While judges Grace Dent and John Torode praised elements of the dish, the final verdict proved decisive. Dent applauded the ginger parkin, calling it “incredible, gingery and satisfying,” but criticized the second half of the cake.
“The Le Mis part of it is undercooked and because of that, it tastes a bit eggy,” Dent said, a flaw that ultimately sealed Boe’s fate.
Despite his strong performance throughout the series, including three ‘Cook of the Day’ wins, the single misstep proved fatal in a competition where margins are razor-thin.
READ ALSO
Viewers React: ‘Alfie Should Still Be There’
Almost immediately after the episode aired, Celebrity MasterChef viewers took to X (formerly Twitter) to vent their frustration. Many described themselves as “gutted,” arguing that Boe’s overall consistency should have carried more weight than one imperfect bake.
One fan wrote:
“I’m gutted Alfie has gone. He’s done such good dishes and fought his nerves every step of the way. He should still be there.”
Another added:
“Alfie should have stayed. Missing a major team challenge should matter more than one cake going wrong.”
The reaction underscored Boe’s popularity throughout the series and his unexpected evolution from nervous contestant to confident, creative cook.
Alfie Boe Breaks Silence After Emotional Exit
Despite the disappointment, Alfie Boe remained gracious in defeat, reflecting positively on his MasterChef journey.
“This has been quite precious,” he said. “These moments in life that come about are really special. I’m happy to be going home as a Celebrity MasterChef finalist.”
His comments struck a chord with fans, many of whom praised his humility and emotional openness throughout the competition.
Who Are the Celebrity MasterChef 2025 Finalists?
With Boe’s elimination, Dawn O’Porter, Alun Wyn Jones, and Ginger Johnson advanced to the final, where they faced the daunting Chef’s Table challenge at The Boat, a three-rosette restaurant in Lichfield led by chef patron Liam Dillon.
The Celebrity MasterChef 2025 final airs Friday, December 19, at 8pm on BBC One and BBC iPlayer, where one remaining contestant will be crowned champion.
FAQ
Why was Alfie Boe eliminated from Celebrity MasterChef 2025?
Alfie Boe was eliminated after judges felt part of his tribute cake was undercooked and tasted “eggy,” despite strong praise for the ginger parkin element.
What dish did Alfie Boe cook on Celebrity MasterChef?
He prepared a two-layer cake dedicated to his late father, combining Yorkshire ginger parkin with a Belgian cake inspired by Les Misérables.
How did fans react to Alfie Boe’s exit?
Fans were overwhelmingly disappointed, calling the decision unfair and saying Boe deserved a place in the final due to his consistent performance.
How old is Alfie Boe?
Alfie Boe is 52 years old.
Who are the Celebrity MasterChef 2025 finalists?
The finalists are Dawn O’Porter, Alun Wyn Jones, and Ginger Johnson.
When is the Celebrity MasterChef 2025 final?
The final airs on Friday, December 19, 2025, at 8pm on BBC One and BBC iPlayer.
Did Alfie Boe win any challenges on Celebrity MasterChef?
Yes. Alfie Boe won Cook of the Day three times, making his elimination particularly controversial among viewers.
What did Alfie Boe say after leaving MasterChef?
He described the experience as “precious” and said he was grateful for the journey, despite missing out on the final.