5 Years, No Trophies With Big Signings: Should Arteta be Sacked?

Mikel Arteta‘s tenure at Arsenal, although initially met with optimism, has become increasingly criticized, especially following their recent FA Cup exit to Manchester United. This defeat, a 1-1 draw with a subsequent 5-3 penalty loss, has led many to question Arteta’s ability to deliver silverware despite heavy investment in the squad. Arsenal’s failure to secure a major trophy in over four years, despite significant signings such as Kai Havertz, Gabriel Jesus, Declan Rice, Mikel Merino, and Riccardo Calafiori, raises serious concerns about Arteta’s long-term viability as manager.

Underwhelming Performance Despite Heavy Investment

Since Arteta’s arrival in December 2019, Arsenal’s hierarchy has trusted him to rebuild a squad that had fallen from its once-dominant position in English football. In the years following his appointment, Arsenal made significant investments in new talent, hoping that Arteta would be able to turn these players into world-class. Among the most high-profile signings were Kai Havertz, Gabriel Jesus, Declan Rice, Mikel Merino, and Riccardo Calafiori, players who were supposed to elevate the team to the next level.However, despite these expensive acquisitions, the results have largely been disappointing.

Havertz, for example, has struggled to find consistency in front of goal, which was particularly evident in the FA Cup loss to Manchester United, where he missed a crucial penalty during the shootout. The German midfielder, who joined Arsenal for a hefty transfer fee, has failed to replicate the form he displayed at Bayer Leverkusen, making his role in the team less effective than initially expected.Gabriel Jesus, who was brought in to solve Arsenal’s attacking woes, has faced recurring injuries, preventing him from establishing himself as a consistent and reliable figure in the squad.

READ ALSO

Guardiola’s Dilemma: Is it Time to Leave Man City or Football?

4-Game Winless Streak: Can Chelsea Survive EPL Second Half?

Salah, Saka, Amad: Ranking EPL Best Wingers in 2024/25 Season

Jesus has shown glimpses of his quality when fit, but the ongoing fitness issues have raised doubts about whether Arteta’s reliance on him as the main striker is sustainable.Declan Rice was a great signing and is regarded as one of the best midfielders in the Premier League. However, even with his high-profile arrival, Arsenal has struggled to assert dominance in midfield. Meanwhile, Rice has yet to reach the peak of his potential at the Emirates, and his performances have been inconsistent, which has contributed to the team’s inability to control games effectively, particularly in high-pressure situations.

Furthermore, Mikel Merino, while solid, has not yet made the kind of impact that was expected of him, and Riccardo Calafiori, though a promising left-back, has been largely out of Arteta’s starting lineup and hasn’t contributed significantly to the team’s defensive or attacking needs. These performances highlight the dissonance between the large sums spent on the squad and the actual impact these players have had on the pitch.

Stagnation in Player Development

One of the most disappointing aspects of Arteta’s reign has been the stagnation of some of Arsenal’s younger talents. Players like Emile Smith Rowe and Chido-Obi Martins, who showed promise under Arteta, have not been given enough consistent opportunities in the first team. Both players were regarded to be future stars for Arsenal, but their development has been stunted, and they have not been able to break into the squad as expected.

Smith Rowe, for example, struggled to reclaim his place in the starting XI following injury, despite showing flashes of brilliance in previous seasons. However, this season, he secured a move to Fulham where he has shown talent which could be more effective if he was with the Gunners.

Asides, Smith Rowe, Chido-Obi is another bright talent from Arsenal’s Academy who wasn’t given the opportunity to show his talent for the Gunners senior team and with such disappointment, he switched over to Manchester United academy where he has continued to show his brilliance and is expected to be among the Red devil’s senior team if he maintains such consistency.

No Major Trophies in Over Four Years

Perhaps the most significant critique of Arteta is his inability to deliver silverware, despite being in charge for over four years. Arsenal’s trophy drought now stretches to more than four years, a situation that is unacceptable for a club of Arsenal’s stature. While Arteta did win the FA Cup in his first season in charge, the lack of any meaningful success in subsequent years is troubling.The recent FA Cup loss to Manchester United is a further blow to Arteta’s legacy.

Arsenal has invested heavily in the squad, but the failure to win domestic cups or challenge seriously for major titles reflects poorly on the manager’s ability to deliver when it matters most. In modern football, managers are judged on trophies, and Arteta’s inability to add silverware to his name after heavy investment in the squad suggests that he may not be the right man to lead Arsenal back to its former glory.

Conclusion: Time for a Change?

While Arteta’s vision and tactical approach initially appeared promising, the consistent lack of silverware and underwhelming performances in key moments raise serious questions about his ability to take Arsenal forward. The heavy investments in players like Havertz, Rice, and Jesus have yet to yield the expected returns, and the tactical inflexibility, lack of in-game adjustments, and stagnation of key players only add to the concerns surrounding his managerial abilities.

Given the high expectations placed on Arteta and the resources Arsenal have invested in him, it is hard to ignore the mounting pressure for a change. Arsenal fans, who have long demanded a return to the top, are growing impatient, and it may be time for the club’s hierarchy to consider whether Arteta is the right man to lead them back to their former glory. A fresh managerial direction could potentially spark the necessary changes to end Arsenal’s long trophy drought and set them back on course for success.