2024 FIFA Best XI: Reasons for Palmer’s Exclusion, Yamal’s Selection

The FIFA Team of the Year is a recognition reserved for the finest footballers on the planet, celebrating their consistency, impact, and exceptional performances throughout the year. In 2024, two young prodigies—Chelsea’s Cole Palmer and Barcelona’s Lamine Yamal; commanded widespread attention for their incredible form. However, while Yamal earned a spot in the FIFA Team of the Year, Cole Palmer was absent. This has sparked significant debate, with fans and pundits analyzing the reasons behind these decisions. Hence, this piece is set to explore Palmer’s achievements, with reasons for his exclusion and why Yamal was chosen.

Cole Palmer’s 2024: A Breakout Year

At 22 years old, Cole Palmer has blossomed into a vital figure for Chelsea after making a high-profile move from Manchester City in 2023. In a struggling season for Chelsea, Palmer stood out as a creative player, consistently delivering high-quality performances in domestic competitions.

Notable Achievements

Palmer’s ability to step up in big moments, including scoring decisive goals against Arsenal and Manchester United last season, was pivotal in Chelsea’s desire to secure a European qualification. In addition, he operates across the front line and in midfield, demonstrating adaptability and intelligence in various tactical setups. Furthermore, Palmer was awarded the Premier League Young Player of the Year (2023/24) for his contributions, a proof of his influence at Stamford Bridge.

Analysis of His Exclusion

Despite his excellent form in the Premier League for the Blues, Palmer’s exclusion from the FIFA Team of the Year can be attributed to a few key factors, which will be addressed critically below;

While Chelsea showed improvement under Mauricio Pochettino, in particular towards the end of the 2023/24 season they did not challenge for major trophies in 2024. The FIFA Team of the Year often favors players from clubs that achieve significant trophies.

Moreover, Palmer did not have a defining moment on the international stage in 2024. England’s Euro 2024 campaign ended in disappointment, and Palmer played a secondary role in Gareth Southgate’s squad. Although he delivered some impactful moments when brought on as a substitute, but for a player like Palmer to break into the FIFA best team, he should be a regular starter for his national side.

Finally, the attacking midfield/winger spots are fiercely competitive, often times each year in the FIFA best team selection, it shows the strongest competitions with players like Lionel Messi, Kylian Mbappé, and Lamine Yamal dominating global headlines.

READ ALSO

Five Improvements Maresca has made in Chelsea

Antony: Any hope for the Brazilian in United?

Amad Diallo: Man United prodigy’s transition to global sensation

Lamine Yamal: A Phenomenal Prodigy

Lamine Yamal, Barcelona’s 17-year-old sensation, had a truly extraordinary 2024. While Palmer excelled in the Premier League, Yamal’s performances for both club and country were nothing short of game-changing. His inclusion in the FIFA Team of the Year reflects his influence across multiple competitions.

Notable Achievements

Yamal played a pivotal role in Spain’s UEFA Euro 2024 triumph, becoming the youngest player to score in the tournament. His contributions in high-stakes games—including a decisive assist in the semi-finals, highlighted his maturity and composure. Moreover, his remarkable season earned him the 2024 Golden Boy, recognizing him as Europe’s best young player. Not to also forget, Yamal was central to Barcelona’s title charge in La Liga last season as well as this current season, forming a deadly attacking trio with Robert Lewandowski and Raphinha. His creativity, pace, and flair consistently unlocked defenses.

Why Yamal Was Chosen Over Palmer

Now to critically address the reason for this piece, what reasons does FIFA have to use in justifying their selection of Yamal over Palmer regardless of the impressive records and achievements he achieved even with a struggling Chelsea team.

Yamal’s role in Spain’s Euro 2024 win and Barcelona’s dominance in La Liga gave him a distinct edge. The FIFA Team of the Year often prioritizes players with tangible silverware. In addition, unlike Palmer, Yamal had defining moments on the global stage. His performances for Spain cemented his status as one of the world’s brightest talents.

While Palmer is undoubtedly a young and talented playmaker, Yamal’s dribbling ability, vision, and ability make him a generational talent. His creativity and technical skills often drew comparisons to Lionel Messi. Not to forget at 17, Yamal has become a global sensation. His narrative as a young prodigy excelling at the highest level resonated with voters, many of whom value the “storyline” alongside statistics.

Comparative Analysis: Palmer vs Yamal 2024/25

Statistics	Cole Palmer	Lamine Yamal
Goals (all competitions)	11	6
Assists	6	12
Major Trophies won	–	1 (Euro 2024)
International Impact	Average	Euro 2024 standout
Creativity	High	Exceptional
Versatility	Midfield/Forward positions	Forward/Wing positions

Conclusion: Why Yamal Edged Palmer

Both Cole Palmer and Lamine Yamal had exceptional years, but Yamal’s performances in major competitions tipped the scales in his favor. His contributions to Spain’s Euro 2024 win, combined with his role in Barcelona’s success, showcased his ability to deliver in crucial moments. Furthermore, Yamal’s youthful brilliance and narrative as a 17-year-old phenom provided an additional layer of appeal that is often influential in award voting.

Cole Palmer’s absence from the FIFA Team of the Year should not diminish his incredible season. If he continues his upward trajectory and Chelsea secure silverware in 2025, he could very well earn his place among the world’s best in the years to come.