Odessa A’zion exits A24’s ‘Deep Cuts’ after casting backlash, admits: “I hadn’t read the book”
Odessa A’zion at A24’s ‘Marty Supreme’ New York Premiere on December 16, 2025. Image Credit: John Nacion/Variety via Getty Images
Rising Hollywood actress Odessa A’zion has announced her exit from A24’s upcoming film Deep Cuts, just days after her casting sparked widespread backlash online. The actress, known for her breakout roles in Marty Supreme and I Love LA, revealed that she voluntarily withdrew from the project after realizing the role raised serious representation concerns, and admitted she had not read the source material before accepting it.
The decision came less than 48 hours after news broke that A’zion had been cast in the adaptation of Holly Brickley’s 2023 novel, which is scheduled to begin filming in February under director Sean Durkin.
Why Odessa A’zion’s Casting Sparked Backlash
The controversy centered on A’zion being cast as Zoe Gutierrez, a character described in Brickley’s novel as half Mexican and half Jewish. Following the announcement, fans of the book took to social media to criticize the casting, accusing the production of potential whitewashing and sidelining actors whose identities more closely match the character’s background.
Some online users also shared unverified comments allegedly from Brickley suggesting the character might be rewritten, further fueling backlash and debate around representation in literary adaptations.
READ ALSO
Inside Melania Trump’s $40 Million documentary: Chaos, controversy and a sudden Global pullback
A’zion’s Instagram Statement: “I’m Out”
A’zion addressed the situation directly via Instagram Stories, issuing a candid apology and explaining how the casting unfolded.
“Guys!! I am with ALL of you and I am NOT doing this movie,” she wrote. “I hadn’t read the book and should have paid more attention to all aspects of Zoe before accepting.”
The actress explained that she originally auditioned for the role of Percy, the story’s central music critic, but was later offered Zoe instead and accepted without fully understanding the character’s background.
“I’d never take a role from someone else that’s meant to do it, that SHOULD do it,” she added. “There are a plentitude of people more than capable of playing this role, and I am NOT one of them.”
What ‘Deep Cuts’ Is About
Set in the early 2000s, Deep Cuts follows two music-obsessed twenty-somethings navigating ambition, love, and adulthood. Cailee Spaeny is set to star as Percy, while Drew Starkey plays Joe, a songwriter and Percy’s love interest. Zoe Gutierrez is portrayed in the novel as Percy’s close friend and Joe’s ex-girlfriend.
The project is being produced by Eli Bush, Ronald Bronstein, Josh Safdie, and Sean Durkin, with Blake Mills composing original music. Brickley serves as an executive producer.
Industry Reaction and What Happens Next
Industry observers have praised A’zion’s decision as an example of actor accountability in an era where audiences are increasingly vocal about representation. While A24 has not officially commented on her exit, casting for Zoe is expected to resume ahead of the film’s February production start.
A’zion concluded her statement by saying she looks forward to seeing who ultimately takes on the role, signaling support for a casting choice aligned with the character’s identity.
A Moment Reflecting Broader Hollywood Conversations
The incident underscores the growing scrutiny surrounding casting practices, especially in adaptations of beloved novels. As studios face louder calls for authenticity, Deep Cuts has become the latest example of how quickly audience reaction can reshape a project’s trajectory.
For A’zion, the move may ultimately strengthen her standing among fans who praised her willingness to listen, reflect, and step aside.
FAQ
Why did Odessa A’zion leave ‘Deep Cuts’?
She exited the film after online backlash over her casting, citing concerns about representation and admitting she hadn’t read the book before accepting the role.
What role was Odessa A’zion cast to play?
She was cast as Zoe Gutierrez, a character described in the novel as half Mexican and half Jewish.
Did Odessa A’zion quit or was she removed?
A’zion said she voluntarily withdrew from the project after listening to fan concerns.
Who is directing ‘Deep Cuts’?
The film is directed by Sean Durkin, known for The Iron Claw and The Nest.
Is ‘Deep Cuts’ still happening?
Yes. The film remains in development and is expected to begin shooting in February with recasting underway.
Who stars in ‘Deep Cuts’?
Cailee Spaeny and Drew Starkey are set to star in leading roles.
What book is ‘Deep Cuts’ based on?
The film is adapted from Holly Brickley’s 2023 novel Deep Cuts.
Has A24 responded to the controversy?
As of now, A24 has not issued a public statement regarding A’zion’s exit.
