Lyle Menendez denied parole: What it means for the brothers
Lyle Menendez appears virtually before parole board in San Diego hearing. Credit: California Department of Correction and Rehabilitation
Lyle Menendez, the elder of the infamous “Menendez brothers,” has just been denied parole by the California Board of Parole Hearings following his first-ever hearing, a dramatic 11-hour session that lays bare the enduring controversy, the brothers’ behavior behind bars, and the complex dance between rehabilitation and public safety.
Parole Denied After Lengthy Hearing
On Friday, August 22, 2025, Lyle Menendez, now 57, faced a parole hearing conducted via video from the Richard J. Donovan Correctional Facility in San Diego. After more than 11 hours of testimony, the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation announced that the board denied his parole, finding him still poses a public safety risk.
Parole Commissioner Julie Garland acknowledged Lyle’s genuine remorse and model inmate behavior, but concluded that “anti-social personality traits like deception, minimization and rule-breaking” still lurk beneath the surface.
A key factor in the decision was Lyle’s illegal use of contraband cellphones, a recurring prison rule violation that significantly undermined his credibility. Garland emphasized that “incarcerated people who break rules are more likely to break rules in society.”
A Family United, Yet Opposed
Though the board declined his release, Lyle’s family voiced continued support, expressing disappointment but reaffirming hope: “This denial is not the end of the road.” They affirmed their belief in his rehabilitation and pledged to continue advocating for either new trial, clemency, or parole reconsideration. Meanwhile, Los Angeles District Attorney Nathan Hochman remains steadfast in opposing the brothers’ release, labeling earlier claims of abuse as “lies.”
How It Echoes Erik’s Fate, and What’s Next
This decision comes one day after Erik Menendez, now 54, had his parole denied following a separate 10-hour hearing. He faces some of the same criticisms, rule violations and behavior concerns, and, like Lyle, will be eligible again in three years.
Lyle can request an administrative review within a year and potentially be brought before the board sooner, though full reconsideration won’t occur until 2028, three years from now.
READ ALSO
Erik Menendez denied parole: Why he claimed he killed his parents
KingCobraJFS dies at 34: What to know about his mysterious death
High-Profile Case, Renewed Attention
The Menendez case, which garnered global attention through their televised 1990s trial, has resurfaced in the public eye, partly due to a 2024 Netflix documentary. Despite this renewed interest, the board’s ruling underscores systemic concerns: even high-profile inmates must demonstrate consistent accountability and compliance.
Implications and Open Questions
- Public Safety vs. Redemption: The board’s focus on behavior suggests a more stringent standard in evaluating risk, especially for violent offenders with high-profile legacies.
- Legal Battles Ahead: The family may continue to push for clemency from Governor Gavin Newsom or seek judicial relief through habeas corpus.
- Role of Inmate Conduct: Advances in rehabilitation may be overshadowed by even minor violations like cellphone possession, raising questions about fairness in parole assessments.
