Why did Lucky Montana resign as MKP MP? Here’s what it means for South African politics

In a notable political development, Lucky Montana, former CEO of the Passenger Rail Agency of South Africa (Prasa) and current Member of Parliament for the uMkhonto we Sizwe Party (MKP), has officially stepped down from his seat in the National Assembly. Montana announced his resignation on Monday via his X account, confirming that he had informed the party leadership of his intentions months earlier.

According to Montana, he formally notified the MKP parliamentary leadership on 30 August 2025. His letter was addressed to the party’s Chief Whip, Colleen Makhubela, and the now-suspended deputy, Dr. John Hlophe, confirming his decision to vacate his parliamentary position. “Today my resignation takes effect,” Montana wrote, signaling the end of his tenure in the National Assembly.

[MEDIA STATEMENT]: MK PARTY STATEMENT ON THE RESIGNATION OF CDE LUCKY MONTANA AS A MEMBER OF PARLIAMENT. pic.twitter.com/OCGc2uStOY

— MK Party in Parliament (@MKParliament) December 1, 2025

The MKP quickly acknowledged Montana’s departure, issuing a statement that praised his contributions to the party. “Lucky Montana has served the MK Party with steadfast objectivity, constructive guidance, and principled contributions that have strengthened our caucus and sharpened our collective political effectiveness,” the party said. The statement further highlighted Montana’s calm leadership, strategic insight, and mentorship of younger party members, describing his service as marked by loyalty, courage, and unwavering conviction.

Montana’s political and corporate careers have been marred by controversy. His tenure as Prasa CEO was widely criticized, with many labeling him among the enablers of state capture during the Jacob Zuma administration. In addition, the South African Revenue Service (SARS) recently disclosed that Montana failed to submit his income tax returns for the 2017, 2018, and 2019 tax years, violating the law and raising further questions about his legal standing.

Political analysts view Montana’s resignation as indicative of broader challenges within the MKP. Sandile Swana, a political commentator, suggested that the party’s decision to induct members with pending legal matters has created internal strain. “It’s a sign of the continuing crisis within MK,” Swana said, noting that MPs overwhelmed by legal troubles may be compelled to step down. While the specifics of Montana’s legal issues remain unclear, he faces significant ongoing civil and criminal challenges that likely influenced his decision to resign.

Early this year, I approached the leadership of MKP that I intend stepping down as Member of the National Assembly at the end of the year. On 30 August 2025 I formally wrote to Dr Hlophe & Chief Whip Colleen Makhubela confirming the same. Today, my resignation takes effect.

— Lucky Montana (@LuckyMontana_MP) December 1, 2025

Montana’s departure comes at a time when the MKP is navigating internal instability and public scrutiny over its leadership choices. The party’s reliance on members with unresolved legal matters has drawn criticism, creating tensions that could impact its governance and parliamentary influence. Analysts argue that the trend may continue to affect other MPs, potentially reshaping the party’s future composition and strategy.

Despite stepping down from parliament, Montana remains a member of the MKP and is expected to continue contributing to the party’s broader political mission. The MKP emphasized that he will remain engaged in the party’s activities, particularly in advocating for social justice and the empowerment of marginalized communities, including the ongoing struggle for the emancipation of the black child in South Africa.

Montana’s resignation underscores the intersection of politics and accountability, highlighting the pressures that public figures face when legal controversies intersect with political responsibilities. As the MKP adjusts to his departure, attention will likely turn to his replacement and the ongoing management of internal party dynamics.

FAQ

Q: Why did Lucky Montana resign from Parliament?
A: Montana cited personal and legal pressures, formally notifying party leadership months in advance.

Q: What controversies have surrounded Montana?
A: He faced criticism for his role as Prasa CEO during the Zuma administration and failed to submit tax returns for multiple years.

Q: Will Montana remain active in the MKP?
A: Yes, the party confirmed he will continue contributing to its broader political mission.

Q: How does his resignation affect the MKP?
A: Analysts suggest it highlights ongoing internal instability and challenges with MPs facing legal issues.