Why are the Giants starting Jameis Winston? Inside the quarterback shake-up shocking New York fans
Jameis Winston to start for Giants in Week 11 vs. Packers. Image Source: AZAT TV
The New York Giants are making a major quarterback change ahead of Week 11, naming Jameis Winston as the starter against the Green Bay Packers. The decision follows the team’s firing of head coach Brian Daboll and the appointment of Mike Kafka as interim coach.
According to ESPN and Fox News, rookie starter Jaxson Dart remains in concussion protocol after suffering a hit during Sunday’s 24–20 loss to the Chicago Bears. With Dart sidelined and veteran Russell Wilson struggling, the Giants are turning to Winston, a move aimed at sparking the offense and testing leadership under Kafka’s new system.
A Fresh Start Under Mike Kafka
Kafka, previously the team’s offensive coordinator and quarterbacks coach, reportedly played a key role in promoting Winston. The interim coach has spent the season working closely with the quarterback group and sees Winston as the best fit for his offensive philosophy.
The 31-year-old Winston signed a two-year, $8 million contract with New York in the offseason but has been the third-string quarterback behind Dart and Wilson. Sunday’s game will mark his first appearance for the Giants and his first NFL start since Week 15 of last season with the Cleveland Browns.
READ ALSO
Tony Vitello expected to join Giants as Manager: What his hiring means for San Francisco
Why Winston Over Russell Wilson?
Russell Wilson, 35, began the season as the team’s starting quarterback after signing a one-year, $10.5 million deal. But his early-season struggles, including just 53 passing yards and three sacks in limited relief appearances, have left coaches searching for answers.
Winston’s leadership and experience reportedly swayed Kafka’s decision. Despite his history of turnovers, Winston remains one of the league’s most experienced backups, with over 36 career wins as a starter and a reputation for rallying teams in high-pressure situations.
A Veteran with a Point to Prove
Winston’s career has been a roller coaster since leading the NFL in passing yards (5,109) in 2019 with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. He later spent time with the New Orleans Saints and Cleveland Browns, where he earned a reputation as a passionate locker-room leader.
This week, he’ll face a Packers defense ranked fifth in the NFL, a formidable test for a quarterback seeking redemption. Winston told ESPN earlier this month he’s committed to “helping this team win, no matter the record or situation,” emphasizing his “solutions-oriented mindset.”
Jaxson Dart’s Injury and Team Outlook
Dart, 22, has been evaluated for concussions four times this season, raising long-term concerns about his health. His absence leaves the Giants (2-8) in rebuilding mode with limited playoff hopes, prompting Kafka to explore Winston’s potential as a short-term stabilizer and mentor for younger players.
With Brian Daboll gone and a new interim staff in place, Winston’s performance could influence the franchise’s offseason quarterback decisions. Analysts suggest he could even secure a backup or bridge-starter role for 2026 if he performs well down the stretch.
The Bigger Picture for the Giants
New York’s quarterback shuffle represents more than a tactical change, it signals a reset of team culture. After inconsistent offensive showings and a 2-8 start, the organization is searching for accountability and spark.
Fans are cautiously optimistic that Winston’s energy, leadership, and NFL experience can stabilize the locker room. Whether he delivers results on the field will determine if this move was a gamble or the start of a new chapter for the Giants.
FAQ: Jameis Winston and the Giants’ Quarterback Change
Q1: Why are the New York Giants starting Jameis Winston in Week 11?
A1: Winston is starting because rookie Jaxson Dart remains in concussion protocol and Russell Wilson has underperformed. Interim coach Mike Kafka believes Winston’s leadership and experience give the Giants the best chance to compete against Green Bay.
Q2: What happened to Jaxson Dart?
A2: Dart suffered a concussion in Week 10 against the Chicago Bears after taking a hard hit on a fumble play. It’s his fourth concussion-related evaluation this season, leading medical staff to rule him out for Week 11.
Q3: What role does Mike Kafka play in this decision?
A3: Kafka, promoted to interim head coach after Brian Daboll’s firing, made the call to start Winston. As the former offensive coordinator, he has worked directly with the quarterbacks and wants to reset the offensive strategy.
Q4: Why isn’t Russell Wilson starting instead?
A4: Wilson’s lackluster performances and declining mobility have raised concerns. In limited play this season, he completed just 4 of 9 passes for 53 yards, failing to sustain drives. The Giants see Winston as a more dynamic option.
Q5: How has Jameis Winston performed in previous first starts for new teams?
A5: Historically, Winston has excelled in debut starts — posting strong performances for the Buccaneers (2015), Saints (2021), and Browns (2024). He has a 3-0 record with 8 touchdowns and zero interceptions across his last two debuts.
Q6: What does this mean for Winston’s future with the Giants?
A6: If Winston performs well, he could secure a longer-term role as the primary backup or bridge starter in 2026. His two-year contract and proven mentorship of young players make him valuable to the Giants’ rebuilding effort.
Q7: When and where will Winston make his Giants debut?
A7: Winston’s first start for New York will be on Sunday, November 16, 2025, at MetLife Stadium against the Green Bay Packers.
