Angie Motshekga orders shock inquiry as Iran defies Ramaphosa’s Naval drill ban

South Africa’s Defence Minister Angie Motshekga is facing intense political and diplomatic scrutiny after ordering a Board of Inquiry into why Iranian warships allegedly continued participating in a multinational naval exercise despite a direct instruction from President Cyril Ramaphosa to withdraw them.

The controversy centres on Exercise Will for Peace, held in False Bay near Cape Town, where three Iranian naval vessels reportedly remained active even after the presidency raised concerns about the geopolitical fallout of hosting Iran amid heightened tensions with the United States.

What Triggered the False Bay Naval Controversy?

According to multiple reports, President Ramaphosa instructed the South African National Defence Force (SANDF) to remove Iran from the exercise due to diplomatic sensitivities, particularly as the US Congress debates the renewal of the African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA) and as Iran faces international condemnation over its internal crackdowns.

Despite this instruction, Iranian vessels were observed sailing alongside warships from Russia, China, the United Arab Emirates, and South Africa, prompting allegations that the president’s directive was ignored, misrepresented, or diluted within the military command structure.

Vice Admiral Monde Lobese at the Centre of the Investigation

The focus of the inquiry has turned sharply toward Vice Admiral Monde Lobese, Chief of the South African Navy. Media reports suggest Lobese may have failed to execute the presidential instruction, triggering what some analysts are calling one of the most serious civil-military accountability crises in recent years.

The Sunday Times reports that disciplinary action against Lobese is under consideration, although no formal charges have been announced.

READ ALSO

ANC rumors explode: Is Cyril Ramaphosa really facing a political coup?

Angie Motshekga’s Response: ‘The Instruction Was Clear’

Breaking days of silence, Minister Angie Motshekga released a statement confirming that President Ramaphosa’s instruction was clearly communicated, formally agreed upon, and meant to be fully implemented.

Due to the seriousness of the allegations, Motshekga announced the establishment of a Board of Inquiry, mandated to determine whether the president’s order was intentionally ignored or inaccurately conveyed. The board has been given seven days to submit its findings.

“This is not a routine matter,” defence analysts note, pointing out that the inquiry touches directly on constitutional civilian control over the military.

Diplomatic Fallout: US Expresses Alarm

The incident has drawn sharp criticism from the United States, with the US Embassy in Pretoria stating that Iran’s participation in joint naval drills undermines maritime security and regional stability.

US officials also warned that South Africa’s actions risk damaging bilateral relations at a time when economic cooperation remains fragile. Senator Jim Risch, chair of the US Senate Foreign Relations Committee, went further, calling South Africa an “adversary” if it continues hosting exercises with nations considered hostile by Washington.

Is Angie Motshekga Herself Under Threat?

While the inquiry focuses on the Navy Chief, reports from City Press suggest that Motshekga herself may be under scrutiny, with questions raised about her oversight and control of the SANDF.

Opposition parties, including the Democratic Alliance, have welcomed the inquiry but are demanding that Motshekga appear before Parliament immediately rather than waiting for a potentially lengthy investigation process.

“At the heart of this crisis is civilian authority over the armed forces,” said DA defence spokesperson Chris Hattingh, warning that failure to enforce presidential orders could have grave legal, diplomatic, and national security consequences.

Why This Case Matters for South Africa’s Democracy

Analysts say the controversy goes beyond a single naval exercise. It raises fundamental concerns about command discipline, transparency, and accountability within the SANDF, especially as senior military leaders have previously expressed support for closer ties with Iran.

If the inquiry confirms that a presidential directive was disregarded, it could signal a dangerous erosion of civilian control, one of the cornerstones of South Africa’s constitutional democracy.

FAQ

Who is Angie Motshekga?

Angie Motshekga is South Africa’s Minister of Defence and Military Veterans, responsible for overseeing the SANDF and ensuring civilian control over the military.

Why is Angie Motshekga in the news?

She ordered a Board of Inquiry after Iranian warships allegedly continued participating in a naval exercise despite a direct withdrawal instruction from President Cyril Ramaphosa.

What is Exercise Will for Peace?

It is a multinational naval exercise held in False Bay involving South Africa, China, Russia, the UAE, and controversially, Iran.

Did Iran ignore President Ramaphosa’s order?

The inquiry will determine whether the order was ignored, misrepresented, or improperly executed by military leadership.

Who is Vice Admiral Monde Lobese?

He is the Chief of the South African Navy and is reportedly under investigation for failing to enforce the withdrawal directive.

Why did the US react strongly to the naval drill?

The US views Iran as a destabilising actor and warned that hosting Iranian warships could harm diplomatic and economic relations with South Africa.

Could Angie Motshekga face consequences?

While not formally charged, reports indicate her leadership and oversight of the SANDF are also under scrutiny.

Why is this issue important for South Africa?

The case raises serious concerns about constitutional governance, civilian authority over the military, and South Africa’s global diplomatic positioning.